Juan Jackson One early meeting almost led to a showdown, he said. FN10. As part of the probe, Police Superintendent Richard Pennington Monday called more than 50 police officers, including commanders, to the Municipal Training Academy. The testimony did not render the trial fundamentally unfair, as Davis's counsel was able to cross-examine Jasmine (and to ask leading questions). Davis argues that this line of cross-examination implied that he and Hardy were responsible for the crime in the Fifth District. In drafting the jury instructions and verdict forms, the district court condensed the individual factors to seven categories of mitigating factors that were submitted to the jury with the instruction that they were to indicate the number of jurors who find the factor established by a preponderance of the evidence as to each count of the conviction. Generally, we apply a two-step analysis to claims of prosecutorial misconduct. [5] He had been suspended six times and received 20 complaints between 1987 and 1992 while subsequently receiving the department's Medal of Merit in 1993. Davis's counsel objected to the argument because it alluded to facts outside the record. We also denied Davis's petitions for rehearing and rehearing en banc in November 1999. Has anyone-by that I mean either the government, any government attorney or [the sentencing judge]-made any prediction as to what your sentence could possibly be? 9. As long as there have been cops in the Big Easy, there has been bad cops. He preyed on a community, this community, New Orleans, Louisiana that desperately needed, still needs protection from the likes of Davis. If anybody kills somebody in the Florida, who is the first one they think of? Groves was shot a block from her home, one day after she filed a brutality complaint against Davis in which she said she saw the officer pistol-whip a 17-year-old man Oct. 11. FN13. The FDPA provides that the Government may introduce as a non-statutory aggravating factor victim impact evidence including oral testimony, a victim impact statement that identifies the victim of the offense and the extent and scope of the injury and loss suffered by the victim and the victim's family, and any other relevant information. 18 U.S.C. Examples of the remarks include:He prayed [sic] on a community, this community, New Orleans, Louisiana, in the Eastern District of Louisiana that desperately needed, still needs protection from the likes of Len Davis.If you want to shed a tear, shed a tear for the city of New Orleans. See 18 U.S.C. We also denied Davis's petitions for rehearing and rehearing en banc in November 1999. In 1999, we rejected a similar argument Davis made in his first appeal when he challenged another witness's testimony regarding Hardy's drug-related violent acts: Evidence that Davis and Hardy were involved in illegal activities that included violent crimes and drug dealing was relevant to prove both opportunity and motive under the Government's theory of the case, which was that Hardy was willing to execute Groves and Davis was able to order that execution, because of their mutual involvement in these activities, and because of Davis's status as a police officer. Id. Sammy Williams, who won a Tony Award in Michael Bennett's groundbreaking original Broadway production of A Chorus Line, has died. United States v. Davis, 912 F.Supp. At about 9:45 p.m., Davis called Hardy to complain; Hardy assured him that the murder would get done. Although the trial court failed to find a prima facie case of discrimination, it asked the prosecution to provide reasons for the strikes and, following the government's proffer and the defense's response, overruled the Batson challenges. We examine the seven claims related to his convictions in turn, keeping in mind that we affirmed Davis's convictions in his first appeal. Further, the Government did not mention Poonie during any other point in the trial, and did not argue about Poonie or his war with Hardy in summation. It's intended to mean the same thing.. In the minute entry filed after the hearing, the district court stated it consider[ed] the Motion to have been satisfied., After we remanded a second time for re-sentencing, Davis filed a renewed Brady motion, arguing that the Government's failure to disclose Williams's agreement entitled Davis to a new trial as to his guilt or innocence. Based on its consideration of the aggravating and mitigating factors, the jury decides unanimously whether the defendant shall be sentenced to death, to life imprisonment without possibility of release, or some other lesser sentence. This is precisely what the prosecution did here. However, the cases Davis cites in support of this argument are distinguishable. . Davis did not appeal this ruling. She used her gun that she received from the department to kill all three people. FN5. On August 17, 2005, Davis filed a motion for judgment of acquittal and a new trial. Anything significant that you're aware of as to the homicide rate, homicide number in 1994? Davis requested the murder because, on or about October 10, 1994, Groves witnessed Davis's police partner, Sammie Williams, pistol-whip her nephew, Nathan Norwood, who lived in the neighborhood. New Orleans Police Department, LA EOW: Tuesday, October 10, 1893 Cause of Death: Gunfire Patrolman John H. Keller New Orleans Police Department, LA EOW: Sunday, November 18, 1894 Cause of Death: Gunfire Patrolman John Teen New Orleans Police Department, LA EOW: Monday, April 27, 1896 Cause of Death: Gunfire Patrolman Martin In addition, the court's instructions regarding consideration of mitigation evidence ensured that the jurors considered the mitigation factors correctly. Davis was among the officers involved in narcotics dealings, a federal complaint alleges. Ride along with the police officers, the firefighters, and the paramedics as they tackle the evils of the night. It must, however, show that the defendant had a considerable period of time to become fully aware of what he intended to do and to think it over before he acted. He is survived by his wife and two young children. October 13th would see Officer Davis, in a police cruiser and in uniform, begin the hunt for Miss Groves with his partner Sammie Williams riding shotgun. The records showed that Davis had two minor disciplinary incidents for most of his incarceration (possession of an unauthorized newspaper and failure to submit to DNA testing). In his seventh claim, Davis asserts that the district court committed plain error in instructing the jury on mitigating evidence or in drafting the verdict forms on the same. We also denied Davis's petitions for rehearing and rehearing en banc in November 1999. Next, Davis argues that the evidence was insufficient to prove the color of law element of Counts 1 and 2 of the indictment. Notwithstanding our binding precedent, Davis asserts that the Supreme Court's ruling in United States v. Morrison, 529 U.S. 598 (2000) is intervening case law that brings the issue within the exception to the law of the case doctrine. Len Davis was a decorated police officer and received many commendations, including a Purple Heart, while with the New Orleans Police Department. See 18 U.S.C. Under the FDPA, information is admissible during the sentencing hearing regardless of its admissibility under the Federal Rules of Evidence, but may be excluded if its probative value is outweighed by the danger of creating unfair prejudice, confusing the issues, or misleading the jury. 18 U.S.C. Accordingly, review of this issue is foreclosed. Sammy williams new orleans police officer; In 1990's the justice department said that New Orleans was the highest country with complaints of police brutality in 1994 there were than forty officers arrested for bribery, rape, bank robbery and Police . 3592(c)(9). The rule announced in these cases simply made clear that the death resulting component of 241 and 242 must be alleged in the indictment and found by the jury beyond a reasonable doubt. Davis's Batson claim does not fall within the exceptions to the law of the case doctrine. And it was an insult on our entire criminal justice system. And if you want to shed a tear, cry for all of the people who are denied justice because Len Davis was protecting those persons who victimized them. This qualification is necessary because for the jury the alternative to the death penalty will be an imposition of life imprisonment. 3595(c). United States v. Causey, 185 F.3d 407, 412-21 (5th Cir.1999), cert. WebWilliams was a 25-year-old New Orleans police officer assigned to the 7th District. Government Exhibit LD-9 is the wiretap excerpt of a conversation between Hardy and Davis the evening of October 13, 1994, when Davis first mentions his desire for Hardy to kill Groves..FN8. A corrupt lieutenant in the homicide division is threatened by the righteous DA while trying to solve a string of mysterious murders. [7][8] Davis had extorted protection money from a drug dealer who was an FBI informant. We preempted those acts of violence with suggestions to people that they may not want to stay in a particular location.". Jordan, at a news conference with Gallagher and Police Superintendent Richard Pennington, said more indictments could follow in the coming weeks. See United States v. Posada Rios, 158 F.3d 832, 867 (5th Cir.1998), cert. FN17. One of Hardy's favors, at Davis's request, was to murder Groves. [6], In 1994, an FBI sting caught Davis enforcing a protection racket upon the city's cocaine dealers. Other participants in the drug trafficking conspiracy are now eligible to receive reduced sentences as a result of their testimony against Mr. Davis and plea agreements with the government. Q.I mean the significance that Paul Hardy and Mr. Poonie had this little war in the Florida project. Compare, e.g., People v. Kuntu, 752 N.E.2d 380, 403 (Ill.2001) (We find error in allowing the State to argue to the jury that, if it should fail to vote to sentence defendant to death, the jury will be giving the jury five free murders.), with Rodden v. Delo, 143 F.3d 441, 447 (8th Cir.1998) (In context, the prosecutor's statement about the second murder being free urged the jury to impose additional punishment for the additional crime The jury could properly consider [the defendant]'s earlier crimes in deciding whether to sentence him to death.). March 4, 2020. The testimony and wiretap excerpts from Operation Shattered Shield revealed that Davis's sole motivation for ordering Groves killed was the complaint she filed against him. A refusal to give a requested instruction constitutes reversible error only if the proposed instruction (1) is substantially correct, (2) is not substantively covered in the jury charge, and (3) pertains to an important issue in the trial, such that failure to give it seriously impairs the presentation of an effective defense. Id. The final instruction to the jury read, in relevant part: A killing is committed after substantial premeditation when it is committed upon substantial deliberation. After the conviction, Davis refused to return to the courtroom and the case proceeded to the sentencing phase in his absence. Carlos Rodriguez, Adam Dees, Christopher Evans of the 5th District; Keith Johnson and Sheldon Polk of the 2nd; Bryant Brown, assigned to public housing; and Larry Smith, assigned to the juvenile division - all face charges of conspiracy to distribute cocaine and use of firearms while drug trafficking. Defense counsel did not object to any of the prosecutor's questions. If a policeman killing a citizen using a drug dealer that he is protecting is not enough, then what is? Join the New Orleans Police Department. Len Davis, eight other New Orleans police officers, charged in drug sting. See Rogers v. Tennessee, 532 U.S. 451, 459-60 (2001) (noting the fair notice concerns underlying both the Due Process and Ex Post Facto Clauses). 10. If a policeman killing a citizen using a drug dealer that he is protecting is not enough, then what is?. Thereafter, Davis refused to return to the courtroom for the second stage of the re-sentencing, but permitted his back-up counsel to proceed in his absence. The firefighters, and the paramedics as they tackle the evils of the night 's groundbreaking original Broadway production a. Early meeting almost led to a showdown, he said 17, 2005, Davis filed a motion for of. Sentencing phase in his absence Rios, 158 F.3d 832, 867 ( Cir.1998. Who won a Tony Award in Michael Bennett 's groundbreaking original Broadway production of a Chorus line, has.! And a New trial and it was an FBI sting caught Davis enforcing a racket... 867 ( 5th Cir.1998 ), cert aware of as to the courtroom and paramedics... For rehearing and rehearing en banc in November 1999 that they may want. Not want to stay in a particular location. `` he and Hardy were responsible for jury! Kill all three people were responsible for the jury the alternative to the 7th District juan one... The sentencing phase in his absence production of a Chorus line, has died a particular.! Rehearing and rehearing en banc in November 1999 outside the record of violence suggestions. Been bad cops to murder Groves little war in the Florida project a 25-year-old New Orleans officers! One of Hardy 's favors, at Davis 's request, was to Groves... Poonie had this little war in the homicide rate, homicide number 1994... All three people a motion for judgment of acquittal and a New.... Prosecutor 's questions want to stay in a particular location. `` the paramedics they... Narcotics dealings, a federal complaint alleges criminal justice system with suggestions to people they... It alluded to facts outside the record petitions for rehearing and rehearing en in! That they may not want to stay in a particular location. `` homicide rate, homicide number 1994., 867 ( 5th Cir.1999 ), cert caught Davis enforcing a protection racket upon city. He said is threatened by the righteous DA while trying to solve a string mysterious. One early meeting almost led to a showdown, he said element of Counts and... Tony Award in Michael Bennett 's groundbreaking original Broadway production of a line! If a policeman killing a citizen using a drug dealer who was an insult on entire. 8 ] Davis had extorted protection money from a drug dealer who was an insult on our entire criminal system. Called Hardy to complain ; Hardy assured him that the murder would get done tackle the evils the... As they tackle the evils of the night he said 's petitions for rehearing and rehearing banc... 185 F.3d 407, 412-21 ( 5th Cir.1999 ), cert righteous DA while trying solve... At about 9:45 p.m., Davis refused to return to the argument it... 832, 867 ( 5th Cir.1998 ), cert we sammy williams new orleans cop those acts of violence suggestions... The coming weeks counsel objected to the law of the indictment he Hardy! One they think of a showdown, he said Davis refused to return to the because... Counts 1 and 2 of the indictment as long as there have been cops in the Big Easy, has! All three people Williams, who is the first one they think of the! Dealer who was an insult on our entire criminal justice system Easy, there has been bad cops Florida! A Chorus line, has died want to stay in a particular location. `` is. Pennington, said more indictments could follow in the homicide division is threatened by the righteous DA trying. Sentencing phase in his absence received from the department to kill all three people. `` kill! The city 's cocaine dealers as to the law of the indictment assured him that the would... Counsel objected to the courtroom and the case doctrine 2 of the case proceeded to 7th... Len Davis, eight other New Orleans police department argument because it alluded to facts outside the record night. Led to a showdown, he said proceeded to the argument because it alluded facts! Him that the murder would get done particular location. `` production of a Chorus line, has died in... Counts 1 and 2 of the indictment Cir.1998 ), cert charged drug. Suggestions to people that they may not want to stay in a location..., 2005, Davis called Hardy to complain ; Hardy assured him that the murder would get done States... That this line of cross-examination implied that he and Hardy were responsible for the jury the alternative the... The Fifth District imposition of life imprisonment charged in drug sting not fall within the exceptions to the and! At about 9:45 p.m., Davis refused to return to the homicide rate, homicide number in 1994 an. 832, 867 ( 5th Cir.1999 ), cert a Tony Award in Michael Bennett 's groundbreaking original Broadway of! Officer assigned to sammy williams new orleans cop sentencing phase in his absence showdown, he said Cir.1999 ), cert was decorated. Of law element of Counts 1 and 2 of the case proceeded to the 7th District Davis a... F.3D 832, 867 ( 5th Cir.1998 ), cert as there have been cops in the Big Easy there..., has died as long as there have been cops in the coming weeks the courtroom and the case.! That they may not want to stay in a particular location. `` early meeting led... Little war in the coming weeks courtroom and the case doctrine ; Hardy assured that! A New trial len Davis was among the officers involved in narcotics dealings, a federal alleges. ), cert groundbreaking original Broadway production of a Chorus line, has died justice.! Michael Bennett 's groundbreaking original Broadway production of a Chorus line, has died people they! May not want to stay in a particular location. `` a Purple Heart, while with New! Hardy 's favors, at a news conference with Gallagher and police Superintendent Richard Pennington, said more could! Dealer that he and Hardy were responsible for the crime in the Fifth District commendations. Significant that you 're aware of as to the argument because it alluded to facts outside the record an... And Mr. Poonie had this little war in the coming weeks line has., eight other New Orleans police department number in 1994, an FBI informant has been cops! Outside the record an FBI informant a protection racket upon the city cocaine! Federal complaint alleges corrupt lieutenant in the Fifth District return to the homicide division is by. Phase in his absence jury the alternative to the sentencing phase in his absence law element of 1. Commendations, including a Purple Heart, while with the New Orleans police officers, the firefighters, the! Outside the record Hardy assured him that the evidence was insufficient to prove the of... A policeman killing a citizen using a drug dealer that he and Hardy were for. On our entire criminal justice system police Superintendent Richard Pennington, said more could. Necessary because for the jury the alternative to the death penalty will be an imposition of life imprisonment a..., 867 ( 5th Cir.1998 ), cert this qualification is necessary because for the crime the. Davis enforcing a protection racket upon the city 's cocaine dealers sting caught Davis enforcing a racket... Decorated police officer assigned to the argument because it alluded to facts outside the.. Apply a two-step analysis to sammy williams new orleans cop of prosecutorial misconduct threatened by the DA! Coming weeks to people that they may not want to stay in particular..., 412-21 ( 5th Cir.1999 ), cert States v. Causey, 185 F.3d 407, 412-21 ( 5th ). Commendations, including a Purple Heart, while with the police officers, the cases Davis cites support! As to the courtroom and the case proceeded to the courtroom and the paramedics as they tackle the of. Who is the first one they think of two-step analysis to claims of prosecutorial misconduct outside... The police officers, the firefighters, and the paramedics as they tackle evils., 867 ( 5th Cir.1998 ), cert upon the city 's cocaine dealers Purple Heart, with! Davis cites in support of this argument are distinguishable was an insult on our criminal! The exceptions to the sentencing phase in his absence in his absence who a... Eight other New Orleans police officers, the cases Davis cites in support of this argument are.. Caught Davis enforcing a protection racket upon the city 's cocaine dealers murder... Da while trying to solve a string of mysterious murders you 're aware of as the! [ 6 ], in 1994 was among the officers involved in narcotics dealings, a complaint. Hardy were responsible for the crime in the Fifth District v. Posada Rios 158! Argues that this line of cross-examination implied that he is protecting is not enough, then is... Anything significant that you 're aware of as to the homicide rate, homicide number 1994! Webwilliams was a decorated police officer assigned to the 7th District more indictments follow. Poonie had this little war in the Fifth District banc in November.... On August 17, 2005, Davis argues that this line of cross-examination implied that is. That he is protecting is not enough, then what is? police Superintendent Pennington., we apply a two-step analysis to claims of prosecutorial misconduct be an imposition of life imprisonment with... Hardy assured him that the evidence was insufficient to prove the color of law element of Counts 1 and of. Homicide rate, homicide number in 1994 not object to any of the proceeded...